On Wednesdays, We Betray Jesus

Judas didn’t have to sneak into the room.

He already had a seat at the table.

And for some reason, that bothered me more this morning than the betrayal itself.

Because Jesus knew.

HE KNEW.

He knew who would betray Him, what was already happening in Judas’s heart, and what that betrayal would eventually cost Him. And Judas was still close enough to receive bread from His hand.

Meanwhile, I have spent years giving people front-row access to my life while knowing good and well they were capable of hurting me. Then acting absolutely flabbergasted when they did exactly what their character had been warning me they would do.

And I think what really convicted me this morning wasn’t that Jesus allowed Judas at the table.

It was realizing how many times I’ve kept Judas at mine, not because God told me to, but because I was arrogant enough to believe I could change him.

WHEW.

Because apparently, somewhere between loving my neighbor and taking up my cross, I appointed myself Director of Human Transformation.

No qualifications. No authorization. Just trauma, good intentions, and an absolutely unreasonable amount of confidence in somebody else’s potential.

And the Lord had to ask me something this morning that I really wish He would’ve waited until after breakfast to bring up.

“Are you loving people for who they are, or are you loving them for who you think you can make them become?”

Well.

Good morning to You too, Father.

Because that question exposed something in me that I’ve spent a considerable amount of time dressing up as compassion.

I don’t just see the good in people.

Sometimes I become so attached to the good I believe is buried inside them that I start ignoring the behavior they’re actually demonstrating.

I can recognize manipulation. I can identify inconsistency. I can hear an apology and know when accountability is missing. I can recognize when someone has become comfortable receiving a level of love, loyalty, and consideration they have absolutely no intention of reciprocating.

And somehow, I’ll still convince myself that one more conversation, one more prayer, one more opportunity, or one more demonstration of grace will finally make something click.

As if I’m one exceptionally worded text message away from somebody’s complete character transformation.

Girl.

And the most embarrassing part?

Sometimes I knew.

I wasn’t confused. I wasn’t oblivious. I wasn’t waiting for some grand revelation.

I knew what I was dealing with.

But acknowledging what I knew meant accepting something I didn’t want to accept.

That I could love someone deeply and still be unable to change them.

That I could see their potential and never experience it.

That I could do everything right and still be treated wrong.

And that somebody else’s unwillingness to grow wasn’t necessarily evidence that I hadn’t loved them enough.

That last one?

That one hurt.

Because I’ve spent so much of my life believing that if I could just be good enough, understanding enough, patient enough, and useful enough, eventually people would recognize my value and treat me accordingly.

And when they didn’t, I didn’t always reconsider their access.

Sometimes I reconsidered my effort.

Maybe I wasn’t patient enough.

Maybe I didn’t explain myself correctly.

Maybe they needed more understanding.

Maybe I should try again.

And again.

AND AGAIN.

Until I was emotionally exhausted, spiritually distracted, and quietly resentful of somebody for not becoming the person I had decided they were capable of being.

Which brings me back to Judas.

In Matthew 26:20-25, Jesus is reclining at the table with the twelve when He announces that one of them will betray Him.

Not might.

WILL.

And when Judas asks whether he is the one, Jesus answers him.

Jesus wasn’t confused about the character of the person sitting beside Him.

In John 13:26, Jesus even gives Judas a piece of bread.

And I sat there thinking about how much easier my life would’ve been if I had understood that kindness does not require ignorance.

Jesus could recognize Judas without becoming cruel toward him.

He could demonstrate love without pretending betrayal wasn’t coming.

He could remain who He was without making Judas’s transformation His responsibility.

And somehow, I have managed to confuse those things for years.

I thought loving people meant constantly making allowances for their behavior.

I thought forgiving someone meant restoring their access.

I thought being Christlike meant never allowing someone’s actions to change their position in my life.

And when I tried to establish boundaries, I felt guilty.

As if protecting my peace automatically meant I had stopped loving somebody.

But this morning, I started considering something.

Jesus loved all twelve disciples, but He didn’t share every experience with all twelve.

In Matthew 17:1, He takes Peter, James, and John with Him to the mountain where He is transfigured.

Three.

Not twelve.

And although that passage isn’t specifically a teaching about boundaries, it reminds me that equal love does not necessarily require identical relationships.

Everybody was valuable.

Everybody didn’t occupy the same position.

And I needed that distinction because I’ve been treating access like it’s a participation trophy.

You know me? Here’s a seat.

We’ve been friends for years? Here’s a seat.

We’re related? Here’s a seat.

You apologized? Here’s your original seat back, freshly polished, with complimentary refreshments.

Meanwhile, I’m wondering why my table feels crowded, my heart feels heavy, and my peace keeps disappearing.

Ma’am, you’ve been running an emotional all-inclusive resort with absolutely no admission requirements.

And I don’t say that to suggest people have to earn basic human dignity.

They don’t.

Genesis 2:18 reminds me that God created us for relationship. We weren’t designed to live disconnected from one another.

But being relational doesn’t mean being indiscriminate.

Proverbs 13:20 tells us that whoever walks with the wise becomes wise, while the companion of fools suffers harm.

Which means the people I allow to influence me matter.

The voices I consistently entertain matter.

The relationships I invest my time, energy, and emotions into matter.

And I cannot keep pretending that everybody who wants access to me is necessarily supposed to have the same level of influence in my life.

But here’s where the Lord really started cutting.

Because while I was mentally identifying all the people who had been Judas in my life, I felt that uncomfortable little tug.

What about the times I’ve been Judas?

Excuse me?

Because I was doing perfectly fine discussing everybody else’s character defects.

But mine?

Now we’re getting personal.

And the truth is, I’ve betrayed trust before.

I’ve spoken out of frustration when I should’ve exercised restraint.

I’ve allowed my hurt to become an excuse for being harsh.

I’ve expected people to understand my intentions while refusing to extend the same consideration to theirs.

I’ve wanted grace when I was struggling but sometimes struggled to give it when somebody else’s behavior was inconveniencing me.

I’ve been the person who needed patience.

I’ve been the difficult relationship.

I’ve been the one whose insecurity, sensitivity, or defensiveness made something harder than it needed to be.

And there have been times when people continued loving me while I was still learning how to love them properly.

So who am I to sit here acting like Judas is always somebody else?

Because sometimes betrayal doesn’t come with thirty pieces of silver.

Sometimes it comes through a conversation I shouldn’t have entertained.

Sometimes it’s sharing something that wasn’t mine to share.

Sometimes it’s allowing resentment to change the way I treat somebody who trusts me.

Sometimes it’s using the very things I know about someone to hurt them when I’m angry.

And I don’t like admitting any of that.

I would much rather be the innocent person who was misunderstood, mistreated, and unfairly wounded.

But God isn’t interested in helping me maintain a flattering version of myself.

He’s interested in transforming me.

And transformation requires honesty.

Luke 6:45 reminds me that the mouth speaks from what fills the heart.

So if I’m constantly speaking out of bitterness, suspicion, anger, or resentment, I can’t keep blaming everybody else for what comes out.

Yes, people can hurt me.

Yes, their actions can be wrong.

But their wrongdoing doesn’t automatically make my response righteous.

And THAT is where I had to repent.

Because I have absolutely allowed somebody else’s behavior to influence mine.

I’ve become short with people because I was tired of being disappointed.

I’ve withheld warmth because I didn’t want to appear vulnerable.

I’ve convinced myself that being guarded was the same thing as being wise.

And sometimes I’ve been so determined not to be taken advantage of that I started approaching relationships like everybody was a potential threat.

That’s not discernment.

Sometimes that’s unresolved hurt operating under a very convincing disguise.

And I know that because I’ve lived long enough to understand what it feels like to be disappointed by people I trusted.

I’ve learned how to read a room.

How to recognize changes in someone’s behavior.

How to prepare myself emotionally before somebody has even decided what they’re going to do.

I’ve become exceptionally skilled at protecting myself from possibilities.

But the problem with constantly preparing for betrayal is that sometimes I start treating people according to what I’m afraid they’ll do instead of what they’ve actually done.

And that’s not fair either.

So now I’m sitting here realizing that I need discernment in both directions.

I need wisdom to recognize when someone has demonstrated they aren’t safe for certain levels of access.

And I need humility to recognize when my own fear is making somebody prove themselves against a history they had nothing to do with.

Whew.

Because not everybody is Judas.

Some people are Peter.

Peter was impulsive, emotional, outspoken, and occasionally operating with the confidence of a man who had not thought his entire sentence through.

And if I’m being transparent, I relate to that more than I would like.

In Luke 22:54-62, Peter denies Jesus three times.

Three.

Yet John 21:15-19 shows Jesus restoring Peter and entrusting him with responsibility.

Which reminds me that failure and character are not always the same thing.

Some people are genuinely growing.

Some people are learning.

Some people are repentant.

And some people are simply repeating the same behavior because they’ve discovered that my forgiveness comes with unlimited access and absolutely no accountability.

The challenge is learning the difference without becoming cynical.

And that brings me to Mean Girls.

Because apparently, I have spent a ridiculous portion of my adult life trying to make fetch happen.

Gretchen Wieners was determined to make that word popular.

Regina George told her it wasn’t going to happen.

And bless Gretchen’s heart, she just kept trying.

Which is exactly what I’ve been doing with certain relationships.

Except my version of fetch is emotional maturity.

Accountability.

Reciprocity.

Integrity.

Basic consideration.

And there I am, spiritually dressed in pink on a Wednesday, trying to convince somebody to become a person they have repeatedly demonstrated they aren’t interested in becoming.

GIRL, STOP TRYING TO MAKE FETCH HAPPEN.

Because I can encourage growth.

I can pray for transformation.

I can demonstrate grace.

I can communicate what I need.

But I cannot make another person choose integrity.

And the more I try, the more I risk turning love into control.

That’s the part that really exposed me.

Because sometimes my desire to change people hasn’t been entirely selfless.

Sometimes I wanted them to change so I could finally feel safe.

So I wouldn’t have to grieve the relationship.

So I wouldn’t have to accept that the person I loved wasn’t capable or willing to love me the way I needed.

So I could avoid making a difficult decision.

And sometimes I wanted them to change because their transformation would validate all the time, energy, patience, and emotional labor I had already invested.

Because if they never changed, what did that mean about everything I’d given?

But that’s the wrong question.

Love isn’t wasted simply because somebody doesn’t respond to it the way I hoped.

And goodness isn’t a transaction.

Jesus washed the disciples’ feet in John 13, knowing who would betray Him.

His goodness did not prevent Judas’s betrayal.

And Judas’s betrayal did not make Jesus’s goodness a mistake.

MY GOD.

Because I have spent so much time measuring the value of my love by whether it produced the outcome I wanted.

But what if loving someone well and changing someone are two completely different assignments?

What if my responsibility is to remain faithful to the character God is developing in me, even when somebody else refuses to develop theirs?

What if I can forgive without reconciling in the same way?

What if I can wish somebody well without inviting them back into every intimate space of my life?

What if I can acknowledge somebody’s value without pretending they add the same value to my life as everybody else?

And what if the most loving thing I can sometimes do is stop trying to manage somebody else’s choices?

Because John 13:27 records Jesus telling Judas to do what he was going to do.

Jesus did not need to become manipulative to prevent Judas from making his decision.

And I need to stop acting like I can control outcomes God has never placed under my authority.

I cannot keep somebody faithful.

I cannot make somebody honest.

I cannot force somebody to be considerate.

And I cannot make somebody appreciate access they have repeatedly mishandled.

But I can decide how I respond.

I can decide what I continue participating in.

I can decide whether I’m going to allow disappointment to make me bitter or allow God to make me wiser.

And I can decide whether I am going to continue investing in relationships out of purpose or simply because I’m afraid of the pain that comes with changing them.

Because sometimes I haven’t been maintaining relationships out of love.

I’ve been maintaining them out of guilt.

History.

Obligation.

Fear.

And the desperate hope that one day somebody will become who I’ve always believed they could be.

Meanwhile, I’ve neglected the people who have consistently demonstrated love, loyalty, honesty, and consideration because I’ve been so occupied trying to rehabilitate the ones who haven’t.

And that realization hurts.

Because while I’m busy chasing the approval of people who keep moving the finish line, there are people in my life who aren’t asking me to perform for their love.

People who show up.

People who tell me the truth.

People who correct me without humiliating me.

People who genuinely want to see me become healthier, wiser, and more secure in Christ.

And those relationships deserve my attention, too.

So this morning, I’m asking God to help me become more intentional.

Not suspicious.

Not cold.

Not unapproachable.

Intentional.

I want to love people without assuming responsibility for their transformation.

I want to recognize someone’s potential without becoming emotionally dependent on seeing it fulfilled.

I want to extend grace without making excuses for patterns that are hurting me.

And I want to be humble enough to acknowledge when I’m the one who needs to change.

Because the truth is, I don’t just need God to reveal the Judas at my table.

I need Him to reveal the Judas in my heart.

The places where I’ve been selfish.

The places where I’ve mishandled trust.

The places where I’ve expected more consideration than I’ve given.

The places where I’ve been more concerned with protecting my feelings than examining my character.

And I need Him to remind me that the goal isn’t to build a table full of perfect people.

There aren’t any.

The goal is to become someone who loves with wisdom, forgives with sincerity, and understands that access and value are not interchangeable.

Everybody deserves dignity.

Everybody doesn’t need the same access.

And somebody’s failure to become who I hoped they would be doesn’t give me permission to become somebody I don’t want to be.

So Lord, teach me how to love Judas without trying to become his Savior.

Teach me how to recognize Peter without permanently defining him by his worst moment.

Teach me how to stop confusing my fear of losing people with a divine assignment to keep them.

And before I start rearranging everybody else’s seat at the table, please examine the condition of my own heart.

Because Jesus knew who Judas was.

But the question that has me sitting here this morning is whether I’ve been willing to acknowledge who people are, who I am, and what God is actually asking of me.

I cannot make fetch happen.

I cannot make Judas faithful.

And I cannot keep calling it Christlike love when I’m trying to control somebody into becoming the person I need them to be.

Jesus knew Judas was going to betray Him and still refused to let Judas determine His character.

And maybe that’s the lesson I’ve been missing.

I don’t need to control who’s becoming Judas. I need to make sure that whatever happens at my table, I don’t stop becoming like Jesus.

Next
Next

Grace Offended Me